Blog · · 5 min read
Why email open rates mislead, and what to measure instead
By Y Naga Vamsi, creator of Mailtruss.
On this page
An "open" in email analytics is not a person reading. It is a request for a tiny invisible image. If that request arrives, the message is counted as opened. A lot of things now request that image without a person looking.
How open tracking works
The sending service adds a one-pixel image to the HTML, with a unique address. When a mail app loads the image, the service sees a request and records an open. Nothing else is measured: not whether the message was read, how long it stayed open, or whether a human was there.
What inflates it
- Apple Mail Privacy Protection. For people who turn it on (it is offered in Apple's Mail app), Apple loads remote images through its own servers ahead of time, whether or not the message is ever opened. Those requests look like opens.
- Image proxies. Some mailbox providers load images through their own servers and cache them, so what the sender sees depends on the proxy, not on the person.
- Security scanners. Some corporate gateways open links and load content to check it before the recipient sees it. That can record opens, and clicks, that no person made.
What deflates it
Anyone who blocks remote images, uses a plain-text client, or reads a preview without loading images is never counted. So the open rate can be too high for some audiences and too low for others, and the mix changes without anything about your email changing.
What to measure instead
- Delivery, bounce and complaint rates. These come from the receiving servers and are the signals that decide your sender reputation. They are the reliable ones.
- What happens next in your product. The person confirmed their address, used the reset link, or paid the invoice. This is the only real proof that an email worked.
- Replies. A reply is unambiguous.
- Clicks, with care. A click is a stronger signal than an open, but scanners can generate clicks too, so treat a click within seconds of delivery with suspicion.
What Mailtruss does
Open and click tracking in Mailtruss is off by default and is switched on per sending domain, because tracking people should be a choice you make and tell your recipients about. When you turn it on, treat the numbers as an estimate. The delivery trace, which records the receiving server's own answers, is what to trust: see how delivery works.
Keep reading
- 6 min readHow to read an email bounce: what 550 5.1.1 and 5.7.1 meanA bounce carries two codes and a sentence. Here is how to read them: the reply code, the enhanced status code, the digits that say retry or not, and the codes you will see most.
- 6 min readSPF's ten-lookup limit, and how to stay under itWhy an SPF record that looks fine can fail: RFC 7208 allows ten DNS lookups. What counts, what does not, how to count yours, and the safe ways to get under the limit.